Skip to content
Gift Cards
Order Online for NEXT DAY Pickup
Dips & Spreads
Meats, Cheeses & Olives
Dry Goods
Frozen Food Case
Pasta, Ravioli & Sauce
Entrees
Side Dishes
Soup & Sandwiches
Breads & Desserts
Catering
Cooking Instructions
Contact Us
About Us
Hours & Directions
Menu
Gift Cards
Order Online for NEXT DAY Pickup
Dips & Spreads
Meats, Cheeses & Olives
Dry Goods
Frozen Food Case
Pasta, Ravioli & Sauce
Entrees
Side Dishes
Soup & Sandwiches
Breads & Desserts
Catering
Cooking Instructions
Contact Us
About Us
Hours & Directions
Shop
1 Dz. Buffalo Wings w/Blue Cheese & Celery Pick up ONLY 2/11
1 dz
$20.00
View Item
1 Dz. Cajun Blackened Chicken Wings
1 dozen
$17.00
View Item
6" Coconut Cake
1 slice
$40.00
View Item
6" Lemon Cake
ea
$40.00
View Item
All 4th of July Items to be picked up only on 7/1 OR 7/3. Closed 7/4.
PLEASE SPECIFY IF YOU ARE PICKING UP ON 7/1 OR 7/3 IN THE NOTES SECTION!
$0.00
View Item
Antipasto Platter for 10-12
Serves (10-12)
$90.00
View Item
Assorted Treats Platter w/Small Cookies, Italian Mini Pastries & Brownies - 36 pc
1 dozen
$70.00
View Item
Bake at Home Pulled Pork Empanadas
3 pc
$22.50
View Item
Bake at Home Spinach & Feta Empanadas
3 pc
$22.50
View Item
Beemster Gouda
5.3 oz
$9.50
View Item
BLT Pasta Salad w/Bacon, Tomatoes, Romaine & Mayo
$11.00
View Item
Blue Cheese Dressing
16 oz
$8.00
View Item
Brownies
ea
$5.00
View Item
Busseto Sliced Prosciutto
3 oz
$6.00
View Item
Busseto Sliced Salami
8 oz
$12.00
View Item
Buttermilk Biscuits
1 dozen
$14.00
View Item
Cajun Chicken Wings
1 dozen
$17.00
View Item
Carrot Cake Squares
ea
$5.00
View Item
Castelvetrano Olives
3 oz
$3.00
View Item
Cerignola Olives
3 oz
$3.00
View Item
Chicken & Black Bean Enchilada Casserole Tray
Serves (10-12)
$75.00
View Item
Chicken Caesar Salad
Serves (1)
$13.00
View Item
Chinese Chicken Salad
Serves (1)
$11.00
View Item
Colcannon (Mashed Potato, Cabbage) - Pick up on Friday, 3, 17 ONLY
1 lb
$11.00
View Item
Coleslaw - Pick up on Friday, 9/1 or Saturday 9/2
1 lb
$11.50
View Item
Corned Beef - Pick up on Friday, 3, 17 ONLY
1 lb
$18.00
View Item
Corned Beef Dinner w/Cabbage, Red Potatoes & Irish Soda Bread - Pick up on Friday, 3, 17 ONLY
Serves (1)
$24.00
View Item
Cottage Pie - Pick up on Friday, 3, 17 ONLY
Serves (4-6)
$26.00
View Item
Crudite Basket (Raw & Blanched Veggies w/Herbed Ranch Dip)
Serves (10-12)
$70.00
View Item
Ditallini w/White Beans & Spinach
1 lb
$11.50
View Item
Eggplant Rollatini w/ Cheese & Tomato Ragu
8 pcs
$18.00
View Item
Eli's Brioche Hot Dog Buns - Pick up on Friday, 9/1 or Saturday 9/2
6 pack
$10.00
View Item
Eli’s Brioche Hamburger Rolls - Pick up on Friday, 9/1 or Saturday 9/2
6 Pack
$10.00
View Item
Flank Steak Platter w/Grilled Red Onions, Horseradish Sauce
Serves (10-12)
$165.00
View Item
Flank Steak Platter w/Grilled Red Onions, Horseradish Sauce - Pick Up ONLY 2/11
Serves (10-12)
$165.00
View Item
French Brie Rounds
7 oz
$5.00
View Item
Fresh Mozzarella w/RRP, Tomato & Basil Pesto
ea
$13.50
View Item
Fresh Pea & Mint Soup
24 oz
$10.00
View Item
Full Rack BBQ Baby Back Ribs
ea
$28.00
View Item
Gazpacho
24 oz
$15.00
View Item
Green Beans w/Arugula & Shallots
1 lb
$11.50
View Item
Green Velvet Cupcakes - Pick up on Friday, 3, 17 ONLY
ea
$4.00
View Item
Grilled Jersey Corn & Black Bean Salad - Pick up on Friday, 9/1 or Saturday 9/2
1 lb
$11.00
View Item
Heirloom Tomato Panzanella Salad - Pick up on Friday, 9/1 or Saturday 9/2
1 lb
$12.50
View Item
Herb Roasted Turkey w/French Brie, Honey Mustard, Lettuce & Tomato
ea
$13.50
View Item
House Made BBQ Sauce
$8.00
View Item
House Made Vegetarian Baked Beans
1 lb
$11.00
View Item
Imported Cheese Platter
Serves (10-12)
$90.00
View Item
Irish Soda Bread from NYC - Pick up on Friday, 3, 17 ONLY
1 lb loaf
$10.00
View Item
Italian Combo w/Provolone, RRP, Lettuce, Tomato & Balsamic Vinaigrette
11
$13.50
View Item
Jersey Fresh Blueberry Cake - Pick up on Friday, 9/1 or Saturday 9/2
pc
$5.00
View Item
Kalamata Olives
3 oz
$3.00
View Item
Kebobs - Bell & Evans Chicken (2 Skewers) - Pick up on Friday, 9/1 or Saturday 9/2
$20.00
View Item
Kebobs - Vegetable (2 Skewers) - Pick up on Friday, 9/1 or Saturday 9/2
$10.00
View Item
Kebobs - Wild Caught Shrimp (2 Skewers) - Pick up on Friday, 9/1 or Saturday 9/2
$30.00
View Item
LaFrieda 28 Day Dry Aged Bone-In Prime Ribeye
20-22 oz
$50.00
View Item
LaFrieda 8 oz Center Cut Filet Mignon
8 oz
$40.00
View Item
LaFrieda All Beef Hot Dogs - Pick up on Friday, 9/1 or Saturday 9/2
6 pack
$14.00
View Item
LaFrieda Prime 40oz Tomahawk Ribeye for 2
$95.00
View Item
LaFrieda Short Rib Blend Burgers - 6 oz. (4 pack) - Pick up on Friday, 9/1 or Saturday 9/2
4 burgers
$18.00
View Item
Lemon Cake Cupcake
ea
$5.00
View Item
Lemon Squares
ea
$5.00
View Item
Lucy's Albacore Tuna Salad Sandwich
ea
$13.50
View Item
Lucy's Caramelized Onion Dip
8 oz
$6.50
View Item
Lucy's Chicken Salad w/Lettuce & Tomato
ea
$13.50
View Item
Lucy's Cucumber Dill Sauce
8 oz
$5.50
View Item
Lucy's Gift Card ($100)
$100.00
View Item
Lucy's Gift Card ($25)
$25.00
View Item
Lucy's Gift Card ($50)
$50.00
View Item
Lucy's Herbed Goat Cheese Spread
8 oz
$6.50
View Item
Lucy's Horseradish Sauce
8 oz
$5.50
View Item
Lucy's House Baked Crutons
05 lb
$8.00
View Item
Lucy's Hummus
8 oz
$5.50
View Item
Lucy's Mac & Cheese - Tray - Pick up 2/11 ONLY
Serves (10-12)
$65.00
View Item
Lucy's Pico de Gallo
16 oz
$7.50
View Item
Lucy's Pimento Cheese Spread
8 oz
$7.50
View Item
Lucy's Tomato Fresca
16 oz
$7.50
View Item
Mediterranean Penne w/Feta, Kalamata Olives & Radicchio
1 lb
$11.50
View Item
Mezze Platter
w/Labneh, hummus, roasted eggplant spread, pita, carrots & celery
$65.00
View Item
Mi Nina Tortilla Chips
12 oz
$8.50
View Item
Middleneck Clams Casino (Half Dz.)
$18.00
View Item
Mini Jelly Donuts
Half Dozen
$8.00
View Item
Mom's Macaroni Salad
1 lb
$11.50
View Item
Neuske's Thick Cut Candied Bacon
3 Strips
$18.00
View Item
NEW! Talia Di Napoli Frozen Margherita Pizza (Imported From Italy)
Serves (2)
$13.95
View Item
NYC Dinner Rolls
1 dozen
$14.00
View Item
Pancetta Wrapped Pork Loin w/Apple Chutney
Serves (1)
$14.00
View Item
Peach Shortcake for 2 w/Biscuits, Fresh Whipped Cream & Local Peaches
ea
$15.00
View Item
Picholine Olives
3 oz
$3.00
View Item
Plum Tomato & Zucchini
16 oz
$9.00
View Item
Port City Pretzel - Tangy Mustard & Honey
$5.50
View Item
Port City Pretzels - Cinnamon Sugar
8 oz bag
$5.50
View Item
Port City Pretzels - Spicy Hot
8 oz
$5.50
View Item
Port City Pretzels - Tasty Ranch Dill
8 oz
$5.50
View Item
Potato Pancakes - Pick Up Only 12/7, 12/8 or 12/9
2 pc
$7.00
View Item
Pulled Pork Tray for 10 -12 w/Brioche Sliders - Pick up ONLY 2/11
Serves (10-12)
$110.00
View Item
Red Velvet Cupacake
ea
$5.00
View Item
Red, White & Blue Cheesecake Bars
ea
$5.00
View Item
Red, White & Blue Cupcakes
ea
$5.00
View Item
Risotto Balls
12 pcs
$20.00
View Item
0
Your Cart
Scroll to Top